What is a Janka rating?
A Janka rating is a rating largely used by the timber flooring industry to compare the hardness of a floor. Technically, the test involves pushing an 11.18mm diameter steel ball into wood fibre until it reaches half of the diameter of the ball. The force used is then measured in kN (kilonewton) as the Janka rating.
Why is it used?
It is typically used as a sales technique to promote the dent resistance of a floor in comparison to another. Although it is sometimes confused with impact resistance (measured in Joules) which is not correct. The rise in popularity for the terminology relating to flooring can be attributed to marketing used by companies selling high density hardwood flooring – presumably seeking to find a marketable difference over traditionally volumetric timber floor markets.
Is it relevant?
In most cases, no. This has to be one of the most over used and impractical comparison tools in the timber flooring industry. For this reason, the Australian Timber Flooring Association (ATFA) have proposed a change in the way we think about flooring hardness and have subsequently created a table with groupings from Soft – Moderately Hard – Hard – Very Hard.
See the following link to the ATFA guide – https://www.atfa.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/29_Timber-flooring-hardness-1.pdf
Here’s a few reasons why Janka ratings are impractical:
- Janka isn’t relevant to most floors on the market.
a. If a Janka rating is being used on a veneer or wood thickness less than 6mm, it’s irrelevant to the test. Think engineered floors or reconstituted timbers. While the Janka rating advised for these products is almost always based on historic data for the species in its solid form, the reality is that most floors are now combination of materials, engineered to make the overall thickness.
b. They are out of date. The Janka rates advised are largely based on historical data from old growth timbers. Regrowth and plantation timbers dominate the supply chain today. Independent tests on these timbers in Australian Universities reveal the timber is no longer the same rate as historical data suggests.
- The purpose of the rating is misleading. Dent resistance is only one part of the floor’s durability. The overall performance of a floor is a combination of scratch resistance, dent resistance, stability, longevity and repairability – not to mention the appearance! A floor with scratches, gaps between the boards and/or cupping would not be desirable regardless of how dent resistant it was. Focusing on Janka rating diverts attention away from these other critical and more problematic issues. In reality, a balance of stability, longevity, coating durability and long term convenience of maintenance is what a consumer actually wants. It is the floors wear resistance that stands out the most.
- Comparatively, what you want to know is if it is fit for purpose. In reality, a timber floor is going to be walked on (some areas will have higher traffic than others) and with occasional furniture being rearranged. The difference in dent resistance between ‘Very hard’, ‘Hard’ and ‘Moderately Hard’ is negligible in these applications. Let me put that in perspective. If you drop a bowling ball on your floor, all density categories will dent. If you walk on your floor, none of these categories will dent. If you are rolling your new fridge in on a trolley, it won’t dent. Go ahead, pick up a piece of wood in the ‘Very Hard’, ‘Hard’ or ‘Moderately Hard’ categories and beat it with your shoe – see if you can dent it!
There are only very rare occasions when a noticeable difference is shown between ‘Very Hard’ and ‘Moderately hard’ – and that is a situation like stilettos or similar. The difference here is that one will dent deeper than the other. This is hardly worth paying more for or worth your attention. Now, rocks under your shoes scratching the surface… that’s more likely. On that topic, the coating chosen can either have hard, moderately hard or soft scratch resistance. It is the scratch resistance and ability to repair that are far more problematic – yet these are often overlooked. More on that below.
- The most common flooring timber in the history of Australia is Tasmanian Oak/Victorian ash and more recently ‘European oak’ engineered flooring. In Europe and America, these are considered HARDwoods. However, those countries don’t have super hard timber species available in commercial volumes like Australia does. Regardless, these floors have lasted hundreds of years, are fit for purpose and have proven the test of time.
Now that we’ve established important considerations to selecting a floor, let’s discuss a floor that we developed in an attempt to have it all.
Why Australian Oak was designed to be the best floor possible?
Australian Oak was engineered to have the best of all flooring attributes possible. Australian Oak was first developed by the Australian Sustainable Hardwoods (ASH). ASH, at one time, was part of a company who produced the largest volume of timber flooring in Australia. ASH know that Traditional solid flooring has many strengths but it also has a few weaknesses. The weaknesses can be summarised as following:
- They are subject to ‘movement in service’ – ie they can expand and contract or warp with changes to humidity and temperature
- They require careful storage, handling and installation to ensure long term customer satisfaction. The result can be gaps caused by shrinkage, peaking caused by expansion, appearance issues with the coating (to name a few). ASH always recommend you employ an ATFA accredited floor installer
- Wider boards are a higher risk of movement and cost more to produce
- Are more expensive to install and coat
ASH saw an opportunity to combine the best of solid timber flooring with the best of advances in manufacturing and engineering. Don’t know what engineered flooring is? Click here.
- Is a stable engineered floor and is not subject to movement in service which means they don’t warp or gap like traditional floors
- Has a wear layer as thick as traditional flooring – so it can be sanded and repolished multiple times over hundreds of years
- Uses crown cut grain in an attractive wide board
- Has a 25 year warranty
- Can produce up to 6 times more flooring from the same resource
- Is made from a blonde coloured hardwood and can therefor be painted or stained any colour and as fashions change. The floor can be stained to a colour that matches the design intent of that era (rather than thrown away)
- Utilises the revolutionary LED cured hardwax oil coating – which is not too hard and not too soft. A hard wearing coating will not scratch easily but when it does, you have to sand and repolish the whole floor to fix it – this often means all furniture has to be removed and residents have to move out until the remedial works are complete. A soft floor will not scratch but it will mark and scuff easily – however, it can be easily repaired by rubbing more oil in and without having to move out. LED Cured hardwax oil is the best of both. When it comes time to renovate and change the floors colour, it can be ‘cut back’, recoated and cured with the LED light instantly – there is no need to move out while the coating cures and the smell dissipates. Likewise, any damaged area can easily be repaired with minor fuss
- It can be laid over in-slab heating or in front of large windows without gapping between board edges
- Installs fast and easily
- Is more cost effective than solid flooring
- Is designed to be sold either pre-coated or coated after installation so that the edges can be without a bevel
To learn more about Australian Oak, contact an Australian Oak specialist here.